Details

    • Improvement
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Major
    • None
    • None
    • Discovery, OS

    Description

      Hi,

      We have a Cisco APIC these run on UCS Chassis in case ours are the UCS C220 m5. 
      Adding this device only brings back some basic info (ports). Its missing Storage, CPU and Memory along with environmental etc. 

      I can see under our instance /mibs section there are the following mibs. 

      CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-COMPUTE-MIB

      CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-EQUIPMENT-MIB

      CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-MEMORY-MIB

      CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-PROCESSOR-MIB

      CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-STORAGE-MIB

      https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/unified_computing/ucs/sw/mib/c-series/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef_chapter_01.html

      Following above link states the above mibs can be used for these devices.  

      I debugged the device can see how it matches on the OS and then what mib's are being applied. Below is that output, is it possible to get the Cisco APIC updated to add the above Mibs?

      Attachments

        Activity

          [OBS-3766] Cisco APIC
          landy Mike Stupalov made changes -
          Due Date New: 2022/02/25
          Labels New: noresponse

          Hi Alessandro Rizzo, we have not received the additional information requested earlier from you in this issue 'Hi,

          We have a Cisco APIC these run on UCS Chassis in case ours are the UCS C220 m5. 
          Adding this device only brings back some basic info (ports). Its missing Storage, CPU and Memory along with environmental etc. 

          I can see under our instance /mibs section there are the following mibs. 

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-COMPUTE-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-EQUIPMENT-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-MEMORY-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-PROCESSOR-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-STORAGE-MIB

          https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/unified_computing/ucs/sw/mib/c-series/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef_chapter_01.html

          Following above link states the above mibs can be used for these devices.  

          I debugged the device can see how it matches on the OS and then what mib's are being applied. Below is that output, is it possible to get the Cisco APIC updated to add the above Mibs?'!

          Issues without your response will be closed within 2 weeks.

          landy Mike Stupalov added a comment - Hi Alessandro Rizzo, we have not received the additional information requested earlier from you in this issue 'Hi, We have a Cisco APIC these run on UCS Chassis in case ours are the UCS C220 m5.  Adding this device only brings back some basic info (ports). Its missing Storage, CPU and Memory along with environmental etc.  I can see under our instance /mibs section there are the following mibs.  CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-COMPUTE-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-EQUIPMENT-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-MEMORY-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-PROCESSOR-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-STORAGE-MIB https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/unified_computing/ucs/sw/mib/c-series/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef/b_UCS_Standalone_C-Series_MIBRef_chapter_01.html Following above link states the above mibs can be used for these devices.   I debugged the device can see how it matches on the OS and then what mib's are being applied. Below is that output, is it possible to get the Cisco APIC updated to add the above Mibs?'! Issues without your response will be closed within 2 weeks.

          I'm also having an issue detecting Cisco chassis but mine are via blades and the Cisco FI.  I believe the issue is that the analyzer for observium sees the switch OS print and goes "oh nexus, load the switching stuff" and it never gets to loading the compute MIBS even if it works fine on the chassis themselves as the rack chassis don't show nexus information they show the CIMC information.   I'll be happy to open another issue if this one doesn't apply to my scenario. 

          Thanks, 

           

          Debug

          debug Miranda Schwarck added a comment - I'm also having an issue detecting Cisco chassis but mine are via blades and the Cisco FI.  I believe the issue is that the analyzer for observium sees the switch OS print and goes "oh nexus, load the switching stuff" and it never gets to loading the compute MIBS even if it works fine on the chassis themselves as the rack chassis don't show nexus information they show the CIMC information.   I'll be happy to open another issue if this one doesn't apply to my scenario.  Thanks,    Debug
          landy Mike Stupalov made changes -
          Status Original: In Review [ 10101 ] New: Pending Response [ 10000 ]

          Probably trouble in snmp configuration on device.
          Try to switch snmp v2 version..

          Show snmp config from device (apic) without private fields (community/passwords/etc).

          landy Mike Stupalov added a comment - Probably trouble in snmp configuration on device. Try to switch snmp v2 version.. Show snmp config from device (apic) without private fields (community/passwords/etc).
          rizzo Alessandro Rizzo added a comment - - edited

          Hi Mike,

          I've just been over the logs now I've seen failing on the following device is not responding to them...

          CISCO-PROCESS-MIB
          CISCO-ENTITY-SENSOR-MIB
          CISCO-ENTITY-FRU-CONTROL-MIB 

          That's cause it think these need to be the following as I put in the Jira and link the documentation which states these mibs should be used. 

           

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-COMPUTE-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-EQUIPMENT-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-MEMORY-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-PROCESSOR-MIB

          CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-STORAGE-MIB

          I think this might of changed recently with the APIC Models and what MIBs are used. 

          I'll do some digging tomorrow trying outside of obs polling the device to find out what works and doesn't to feedback. 

           

          Cheers

          Alessandro 

          rizzo Alessandro Rizzo added a comment - - edited Hi Mike, I've just been over the logs now I've seen failing on the following device is not responding to them... CISCO-PROCESS-MIB CISCO-ENTITY-SENSOR-MIB CISCO-ENTITY-FRU-CONTROL-MIB  That's cause it think these need to be the following as I put in the Jira and link the documentation which states these mibs should be used.    CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-COMPUTE-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-EQUIPMENT-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-MEMORY-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-PROCESSOR-MIB CISCO-UNIFIED-COMPUTING-STORAGE-MIB I think this might of changed recently with the APIC Models and what MIBs are used.  I'll do some digging tomorrow trying outside of obs polling the device to find out what works and doesn't to feedback.    Cheers Alessandro 

          Hi Mike,

          We've upgraded to latest no change.

          I've attach the discovery as requested. 

          Cheers

          Alessandro 

          rizzo Alessandro Rizzo added a comment - Hi Mike, We've upgraded to latest no change. I've attach the discovery as requested.  Cheers Alessandro 
          rizzo Alessandro Rizzo made changes -
          Attachment New: obs-aci-apic-debug-latest.txt [ 19464 ]
          rizzo Alessandro Rizzo made changes -
          Attachment Original: obs-aci-apic-debug-latest.txt [ 19463 ]
          landy Mike Stupalov made changes -
          Status Original: Pending Response [ 10000 ] New: In Review [ 10101 ]

          People

            landy Mike Stupalov
            rizzo Alessandro Rizzo
            Votes:
            1 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            5 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated: